Showing posts with label • Over The Top Awards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label • Over The Top Awards. Show all posts

Thursday, April 23, 2009

How to Save a House and Create a Home


The current Independent Weekly has a cover story on Builders of Hope. Bob Geary begins the story this way, embedding the beginning of the real story here.

It wasn't only the spike in Raleigh teardowns, though the sight of perfectly habitable homes being reduced to rubble helped Nancy Murray settle on a strategy. She already was on a mission to learn all she could about affordable housing and how to build it. Call it audacity, call it a ministry, but Murray—an advertising executive turned builder and social activist—thought she could supply top-drawer, affordable houses in good neighborhoods to working-class families.

Then it clicked: Murray would save the homes imperiled by teardowns and have them moved to a new location. She would upgrade them using the best green techniques while preserving as much of their old wooden bones as possible, then sell the houses at prices high enough to recapture the costs but below their new appraised values.

Such was the genesis—the biblical as well as temporal meaning—of the nonprofit organization Murray created in 2006, Builders of Hope.


This most amazing story of hope becoming reality can be read here. The chance for hope to recycle itself into the future is the best development of all.

An Over the Top Award to Builders of Hope for this Positive Development.

Wednesday, July 2, 2008

A Positive Development



Raleigh City Council voted in the expedited NCOD on July 1. A round of applause is in order...

The OTT/ITB Award for June goes to the Raleigh CIty Council for this Positive Development.

WTVD:
Victory for McMansion opposers
Tuesday, July 01, 2008 | 4:37 PM

RALEIGH (WTVD) -- Raleigh homeowners hoping to protect their neighborhoods from so-called McMansions can claim victory.

The infill debate about how to regulate tear downs in older neighborhoods has been going on for more than one year.

Tuesday the city council agreed to adopt new rules about how neighborhoods create standards for homebuilding in their communities.

Until now it took neighborhoods two years to amend guidelines for how new homes could be built. The process has been streamlined to take about six months.

Under the new rule, older neighborhoods are able to have a say about nine different categories when it comes to rebuilt homes. Among the categories are housing height and the distance homes are set back from the road.

For more information, visit the City of Raleigh's Website.
(Copyright ©2008 WTVD-TV/DT. All Rights Reserved.)

http://abclocal.go.com/wtvd/story?section=news/local&id=6239195#bodyText


N&O:
http://www.newsobserver.com/front/story/1127168.html

WRAL:
http://www.wral.com/news/local/story/3136711/

Friday, May 16, 2008

OTT Award for May




Fallonia reported the demise of a classic Lake Boone Trail house in summer of 2007. Well sir, the successor is on the market and can be had for a cool $2.49 million.

Take a look around the hood and you will find the price point of the surrounding homes range from $500K and up. Can't find a million dollar home on that stretch, nor a 1.5M house. So what is this?

Here is where FP gets a little hot under the collar. Is this really about revitalizing Raleigh, or is it about replacing Raleigh?

One would think a compatible updated home ranging to the 3/4 mil mark might be a boon(e) to the street, but an outlier like this, with so much investment involved, is not sitting pretty, it is sitting loud.

What happens next?
  • Will it look out of place? or
  • Will it determine the look of this area?
  • Will it attract another similar venture to validate its price in that location?
  • Will it sit unsold, like the one on Glenwood, waiting for that special buyer who wants to take a risk on the most expensive house in a less expensive area?
One thing is certain:
  • It will change the land / house price equation for the residents of this stretch.
Neighbors will welcome or reject this development. There is no way it will just slip in to the existing fabric unnoticed.

See Losing Lake Boone Trail for more hyper-ventilation.

$2.5 M? Even FP is shocked.

Friday, May 2, 2008

Over The Top Award for April


The Over the Top Award for April goes to Foolishness on Fairview.

Fallonia is grieving over this one. Having known the place as the home of friends before, and watching its impeccable renovation in the past 10 years, it came as quite a shock to see it being dismantled this week.

Donning the Sherlock Holmes magnifier, FP has turned up the scoop. With great hope for a crafty renovation, this is revealed:



Are you kidding? This was bought in the fall for over $700K.

Hmm. Obsolete, nope.
Too Small, nope.
Not charming enough, nope.
A Million Dollar address, check.
Investors, mayhaps.

Realtors, could you possibly go back to matching home-buyers with homes that fit them? I know families who would have loved to live in this house, even at this price. Heck, $700K is a steal in these parts, these days. When the deed is done, we will have handed over the charm of our lovely old small town to the highest bidder. It will not be Raleigh anymore.


View Larger Map

Fallonia est très triste ce soir.

Monday, March 31, 2008

Over the Top Award for March 2008


The OTT award for March goes to Entertainer's Paradise on Anderson. Named by its builder, this house is now on the market for 1450 thousand dollars. 

Single Family Property / Bedrooms 5 / Bathrooms 4 / Carrooms 3 / Square Footage 5832 / Lot Size 0.42 acres



Take a stroll up and down the street and you can see what a unique house this is. (Until you meet its inverted twin across the street and down a few.)


View Larger Map


Here is a history of money changing hands for a modest property in a highly desirable area. Stamps divided by 2 equals cash.

% Own / Stamps / Date

ALL / 840.00 / 03-14-2007

ALL / 740.00 / 06-29-2006 (1 back)

ALL / / 04-11-2006 (2 back) *

ALL / 650.00 / 04-11-2006 (3 back) *

* how this works is beyond me.

The flipping fee runs about 45-50 K per.

It took a year for this house to be completed, or 2 years from the first flip to the final house. This is what a settled neighborhood looks like until that time comes.




This builder has 4 lots in play on Anderson Drive. Reports from other established neighborhoods in Raleigh report that each has one or two builders responsible for the lion's share of redevelopment activity. Up on Anderson, there is a lot of door knocking going on -- it is open season for hunting old houses. I am thinking we can rename Anderson Heights to Wakefield Central when they are done.

Friday, February 29, 2008

Over the Top Award for February




The OTT Award goes to Alhambra on Lakeview.

Google map to here, click "street view"

Let me share with you a few statistics.

1.40 acres with house, purchased 2003 for $1.55M. Demolition permit June 2005. New house size is 12,617. Propery valued at $7M, tax is appealed.

This was the original house, my understanding is it was quite the thing in its day. That is the Carolina Country Club golf course in the background.



They don't call it Lakeview for nothing.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Over the Top Award for January 2008




This month's OTT award goes to No Oaks on Claremont.

Just when you think the top has been reached, along comes another contender. We at OTT have been concerned for sometime about the "gone wild" effect that the redevelopment on Claremont has stirred. In previous posts, we have highlighted the contrast that the riverhouse and showboat style homes bring to a street where new homes have already been built in an updated craftsman design. A lovely house, I am sure, but the location on a .38 acre wedge in an R-6 neighborhood seems odd, at best.

R-6 / .38 acres
Deed Date 9/26/2007 Pkg Sale Price $395,000
Heated Area 1,212

Assessed Value
Land Value Assessed $261,000
Bldg. Value Assessed $119,111
Total Value Assessed $380,111




It is important to note that the house getting the squeeze next door is now assessed at less than the purchase price of this property. Their land is now twice that of their house. Do you think they have a chance to get fair market value for their house and land?

I believe the compensation for their eventual sale would be higher if there were bigger and better homes on either side, which would mean their house would have real value. These ultra large new houses (on their right, on their left, and in front, and behind) are grossly impacting this resident's right to enjoyment of their investment. I can only conclude that we cannot count on others to do the right thing, therefore some zoning ordinances need adjusting so that in-town neighborhoods can enjoy orderly and predictable changes that enhance their neighborhoods. From that, all people profit; from this, one person's profit is someone else's loss.

Monday, December 31, 2007

Over the Top Award for December


The Over The Top award for December goes to Balderdash in Hayes-Barton. This historic design is of the eurofabulous influence, not historic old Raleigh. This section of upper Cowper is becoming castlefied one estate at a time.

Price: $ 3,695,000 / Bedrooms: 4 / Total Full Baths: 4 / Total Half Baths: 2 / Garage: 2-Car / Acres: .46 / R-4
Estimated Sq.Ft.: 1300 (?!) perhaps 7500... or 75,000.
House and lot purchased 7/20/2006 for $1.125M.

THIS ELEGANT 'HISTORIC DESIGN' IS NEARING COMPLETION. SLATE ROOF...COPPER GUTTERS....MARBLE FOYER...3 FIREPLACES...1ST FLOOR MASTER BEDROOM...LARGE FORMAL LIVING ROOM WITH FRENCH DOORS TO THE TERRACE...CIRCULAR STAIRSCASE...BEAUTIFUL COVERED PORCH...REAL STUCCO EXTERIOR...CLICK MEDIA LINK FOR PLANS OF THIS FINE HOME. COMPLETION 3/08'.




The history of the neighborhood, as taken from the Raleigh Architectural Survey, notes:
By contrast, the grandest of the second wave of suburbs is Hayes Barton, Raleigh's first twentieth century upper-class neighborhood. Bordered by Glenwood Avenue, Fairview Road, Williamson Drive, and St. Mary's Street, Hayes Barton is an exclusive residential district where pecan and willow oak trees shade Georgian and Colonial Revival houses along streets that bear the names of former North Carolina governors such as Jarvis, Reid, Stone, and Vance. The earliest house here dates back to June, 1920, when the suburb developed by the Allen Brothers and the Fairview Realty Company began its transformation from the cotton fields of B. Grimes Cowper. Marketed specifically towards the high end of the economic scale, Hayes Barton was named for Sir Walter Raleigh's birthplace in Devon, England.

Hayes Barton is one of several upper and middle-income suburbs in North Carolina designed by Earle Sumner Draper, a distinguished landscape architect. His layout of Hayes Barton was similar in overall character to Myers Park in Charlotte; in 1911, John Nolen, a pioneering city planner, had created the Myers Park design which was a highly influential diagram for spatial and social organization throughout the south. There, Nolen formulated components for a successful suburban enclave such as curving streets, greenway parks, streetcar transportation, and a restricted number of entrances. [35] Hayes Barton appealed to the well-to-do with its promise of privacy, large wooded lots, and commuting distance to downtown Raleigh.

Soon after utility linkages and paved roads were installed, there was a rush to build on the 175 acres. The design of the 1920s housing stock followed traditional and popular tastes, mainly large Colonial Revival houses. The majority of dwellings are two stories tall, built of masonry, with gable roofs and handsome restrained classical details. A substantial proportion of the houses are custom designs by local architects such as Thomas W. Cooper, William H. Deitrick, Charles Atwood, Arthur C. Nash, and James A. Salter. The most prolific builders in Hayes Barton were James A. Davidson, C. V. York, Howard Satterfield, John W. Coffey, and Roland Danielson. In some cases these men built from architects' designs, but some, such as Satterfield, designed as well as built houses. Nearly half of all the dwellings in Hayes Barton were erected during the 1920s; they were inhabited by insurance agents and bankers, physicians and attorneys, salesmen and administrators, many of whom were employed in downtown Raleigh. Hayes Barton was and is an area of impeccably manicured landscapes, and pristinely maintained residences which still house some of the capital city's political and social leaders.


A drive through the neighborhood reveals a diminishing mix of housing styles. Some of the later homes were built during earlier waves of infill. These houses are meeting with the wrecking ball and houses surpassing the current median value are taking their place. Watch out for the day when the older fine homes are deemed insufficient.

Sunday, December 2, 2007

Over the Top Award for November


November's OTT award winner is Chateau Chêne Blanc. Almost complete, this home takes its place on a 1+ acre lot alongside other generously-sized properties on White Oak Rd. The land beneath this house is recently valued over $900,000. No record of the purchase price is available, it is zoned R-4.




OTT reported the original home's disappearance in June and September. Part of a continuing change on the major avenues, the mix of older homes and several new Over The Top houses and subdivisions are doing everything but blending together these days.

BTW, this lack of blend is duly noted on the City-Data Forum. After a wonderful description of life ITB, it concludes with this advice:

Be advised that living ITB comes with a cost premium. You will get less house (s.f.) than elsewhere. You will pay more per s.f. when you buy or rent. But, for those of us who think life is more about what happens outside our immediate property than inside, I highly recommend you give it a good long look.


Then a poster adds this:
I have read a little about tear down neighborhoods - problems with large homes over shadowing smaller older ones. Are certain neighborhoods more prone to this??

Some neighborhoods have fought for historic designation to ward off such vile activity. However, there are some neighborhoods where the existing home is in such bad repair that the cost of fixing it up is higher than scraping and building new. In these cases, you might see an appropriately scaled new home in a historic district.

If I were trying to avoid the most amount of scraping, I'd avoid Anderson Heights (Anderson Drive and White Oak Rd area). There is a lot of this sort of activity going on there mainly because there are lots of small homes on large lots near some of the most oustanding homes in the city. However, it's not just the small homes being scraped. Sometimes big homes are torn down in favor of even bigger, fancier ones. When they are done, there won't be any small(ish) homes in that neighborhood.
As for the neighborhoods that see less of this activity, I'd say that Cameron Park, Oakwood, Mordecai, Boylan Heights and Glenwood/Brooklyn are safer bets.


That takes us back full circle. I will miss the graceful older homes and the people who graced them.

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Over the Top Awards for October


This month's Over The Top award goes to:

Xanadu on Oberlin

You know the one.

Just so you know, that 1.23 acre tract is zoned R-6, which allowed the 13,022 (heated) square foot house to use a maximum footprint. You can see how that looks quite easily by tracking the depth and girth of this project from the road.

This property changed hands twice, first in 2003 and then again in May 2005. Looks like the occupancy permit for this single family home will be coming up soon, the landscaping has begun.

To help you with perspective, 3 doors down is St. John's Baptist Church, which weighs in at 2 acres and 16,773 square feet.

Friday, October 5, 2007

September Over The Top Award



The September Award goes to Midtown magazine and their cover story, the Teardown Phenomenon (hmmm, I feel a phrase lift here...).

The entire story can be found here or here.

A how-to guide to turning an older stable neighborhood into a newer upscale development, one house at a time, the players and their specialties are covered here. This will help one find their own personal concierge service for this exciting opportunity, available to the select market.

There are a few warnings, this one on old growth trees, for example.

“What we have found with working with multiple builders on teardown projects is that they typically want to save some of the mature trees, especially the big Oak trees that have been there for 100 years or more,” says Jeffrey Parkhurst, certified arborist with JD Tree Pros. “The only problem with that is that most builders know how to build houses. They don’t know much about trees at all. So, they put up a small tree protection zone around the base of the tree. The only problem with that is they usually put it up way too small. The root zone of a tree is at least as far outreaching as the limbs and usually 50 percent beyond that.” Parkhurst says once the root system is damaged, a tree can start dying immediately or anywhere from two to five years later, which often leaves homeowners bewildered as to what happened to their gorgeous tree.

The solution, of course, involves having enough money to try to resolve the problem created by having enough money to create the problem in the first place.

Another timely topic, price:
Although some buyers take it upon themselves to tear down old homes and start from scratch, most of the players are builders. To meet the demand of this demographic, many are shelling out upwards of $250,000 for the lot alone. To make the numbers work, they must build big to recoup their costs. “Typically, the lot is about 20 percent of the total value of the house,” says Tom Bland, president of Preservation Homes, who currently has two homes under construction on Nottingham. “So if you buy a lot for $200,000, you’re probably going to have to put a million-dollar home on there because of the numbers. The lot will dictate the price of the house.” A decade ago, paying several hundred thousand dollars for a lot in Raleigh was largely unimaginable for most builders, but the climate of the real estate industry has changed. ...

Some builders quoted showed sensitivity for the history of the area and in the selection of homes to demolish. Others, however, see dollar signs. Few see the economic burden this shifts to the existing residents, but then again, that is how the property will get to market.
“We have seen periods of above average appreciation on existing homes in the Midtown area over the past three years based on increased demand alone. ... Whether or not this continues will depend on a strong local economy, continued growth, redevelopment and demand in the Midtown area. Based on the location, there should be heightened demand for property in this area and rebuilding should continue for the foreseeable future.”


My secret decoder ring says that Property means Lot, not my historic cared-for home. I dunno about you, but seeing my lifetime neighborhood objectified into a luxury shoppers paradise kinda turned my stomach. Embracing change is one thing, this is something else.

Friday, August 31, 2007

Garage Mahal on Glenwood



This house has so many OTT qualities that it is nominated for the belated July and current August Over The Top Award.

There are many things that make this house special. I hesitate to nominate it since it is being built as a private home rather than a spec house. But as I walked the neighborhood, it was clear this one is Over The Top from so many perspectives, it could become the poster house for defining the problems of over-sized rebuilds in old neighborhoods. Let me count the ways.




1) Streetscape: The original house on this lot blended with its neighbors. When in doubt remember this handy formula:
Streetscape = S1 + S2 + S3, where S1 = Setback, S2 = Style, and S3 = Size





2) Impact on existing neighbors: this courtesy can be accomplished by careful design. Pay attention to height, setbacks, views, tree canopy, and possible runoff from large amounts of impervious surfaces. Your neighbors will love you for it.



3) Respect neighborhood quality of life: this ambiance is what attracted you here in the first place. Lifetimes were spent tending this ground for future generations' enjoyment.






Up close and personal ...






This property was purchased for $385,000 in June 2005. Two years in the making, and still going, this house may single-handedly change the character and tax values of this section of Glenwood Avenue and the settled community behind it. We can be all for rights, but one's rights should require balancing with the impact such freedom can have on the wider public and private realm. I am certain that is why they invented zoning regulations.

Saturday, June 30, 2007

Favorable Outcome on Anderson

This month's award is going to a Positive Development. You can see in these pictures that a 1940's house is enlarged, updated, and basically recreated without major expansion into the setbacks or sky. Nestled in the old trees, this house makes perfect sense.

Before


And After



Sorry about this angle, but good builders deserve credit.

Friday, May 18, 2007

The Castle on Cooleemee


The house being built nearby is finally on the market, after 1.5 years in the making. It gets the Over The Top award for May.

Let's look at the finer details:

Stately European Style Masterpeice [sic] Raleigh, NC - Luxurious Architect Designed European Executive Home*10ft Ceilings, 1st Flr Mstr Suite, Vaulted Great Rm, Gourmet Kit w/Viking Appl incl Built-in Viking Refrig, Custom Cabinetry & Millwork thru out, Granite Kit and Mstr Countertops, French Tilework, Energy Star Rated Home w/Generous Qty of Hurd Low E Maint Free Alum Clad Windows, Ext Fireplace & Beautiful Landscaping at Completion.

. . .

All for the tidy sum of $1,190,000. The likes of this have never been seen on the side streets on Anderson Heights before. It replaced a white clapboard home with 2 bedrooms and one bath nestled up a slight hill. There were mature dogwoods in the front and hardwood and pines on the side and back. Several trucks were required to haul off the trees that were removed for this.

It stands between two one-story houses that were also here for the past 60 years. At the realtor's site, they show the site-plan -- all building and driveway. It sits exactly on the prescribed setbacks, including a 2 car garage. This one was featured in a story by WRAL on the infill phenomena. Its price is multiple times that of existing homes.

Note that when a new home is built on an old lot, the builder must respect the setbacks, but not the surroundings. In this case that would be 10 foot sideyards, and 30 feet from front and back lines. I cannot figure out where there is room for all those trees in the sketch.



If you look at this new home in this location, do you wonder how long it will take for the rest of the block to be torn down and rebuilt to its standards, or do you think it looks out of place? That is the million dollar question.